Vista SP1 no faster than stock OS, say testing experts

Gregg Keizer   Today’s Top Stories   or  Other Windows Stories  

Moving to Windows Vista: The Promise, The Reality Take Control! Managing Your Application Library The Advantages of Migrating to Windows Vista® and Office 2007 Simultaneously The Importance of Application Management Windows Vista®: A Cyber Security Shield Windows Vista: Necessity and Opportunity SaaS Solutions for Remote Systems Management Compterworld Technology Briefing: Intelligent Users Use Business Intelligence Computerworld Report- Large Enterprises Pay More for IPAM Sign up to receive Windows Resource Alerts

November 19, 2007 (Computerworld) -- Windows Vista Service Pack 1 (SP1) is not measurably faster than the original stock edition, a Florida-based developer of performance testing and network metrics software said today.

"Microsoft has hinted that SP1 is faster than Vista RTM," said Craig Barth, the chief technology officer at Devil Mountain Software, referring to the release to manufacturing version of the operating system. "But we found pretty much nothing measurable. It surprised me as much as it surprised everyone else, but the numbers are the numbers."

Devil Mountain ran its DMS Clarity Studio framework on a laptop Barth described as a "barn burner" -- dual-core processor, dedicated graphics, and either 1GB or 2GB of memory -- to compare performance of the SP1 release candidate that Microsoft Corp. released last week with the RTM version that hit general distribution last January. The Vista RTM was not updated with any of the bug fixes, patches or performance packs that Microsoft has pushed through Windows Update since the operating system's debut.

"One gigabyte, 2GB [of memory], it didn't make a difference," said Barth. "SP1 was never more than 1% or 2% faster."

The difference between Vista RTM and SP1 on Devil Mountain's Microsoft Office-based test script was "statistically insignificant," Barth said, while a multitasking test panel produced results for SP1 less than 1% faster than RTM.

"Our goal wasn't to bash Vista," said Barth. "We've been doing this for a while, we know how to do it, and we tried to be as clinical as possible. But SP1 is not going to be a panacea for any performance problems users have with Vista. If you've been disappointed with the performance of Windows Vista, you're not going to be any happier with SP1."

The bottom line: It's Vista's architecture and feature set -- Barth cited Volume Shadow Copy, Vista's snapshot service, as an example -- not a lack of fine-tuning or bug fixes that makes it perform poorly on PCs that run Windows XP blazingly fast.

Microsoft has touted a pair of performance packs that it has delivered to Vista users via Windows Update and that have also been rolled into SP1. The updates, issued most recently just last week, have included fixes for such performance-related issues as slow waking from power-saving states. Microsoft was not immediately available to comment on the Monday test results.

Barth also said Devil Mountain is kicking off a community-based testing network, dubbed exo.performance.network, that it hopes can grow into an industry metrics resource. Users who register receive access to some of the company's testing scripts and a Web-based portal where results are shared. Some software must be downloaded and installed on the user's PC.

Related News and Discussion:

• Vista speed, stability fixes to hit Windows Update on Tuesday
• Windows Vista A to Z
• Ding! Mac vs. PC cost analysis, Round II
• Joyce Carpenter's blog: Mac OS X better than Vista which is better than XP which is better than ...
• Ballmer: Linux users owe Microsoft
• Readers blast Ballmer for saying Linux users owe Microsoft

Print this Story

Send Us Feedback

E-mail this Story

Digg this Story

Slashdot this Story

"After too much denial, Apple has finally admitted that Mac users need to install anti-virus software. Now it's time for..." Read more... "Todd Bishop at TechFlash had a great summary last week of some e-mails revealed during the Vista Capable lawsuit that..." Read more... Read more Windows posts or See all Blogs

Windows users indifferent to Microsoft patch alarm, says researcher Tech jobs down sharply but not out Apple yanks antivirus advice from its Web site More top stories...

Microsoft slates 8 bug updates for year's final Patch Tuesday De Beers tries to force spoof news Web site offline over fake ad Microsoft confirms Yahoo's Lu to run online services

Review: The new MacBook Air, now with extra SSD goodness Thin as ever, the latest Air offers up to twice the storage and snappy performance. Cool Stuff: Your 2008 Holiday Gift Guide We've got an array of economical, expensive, and just plain weird tech gifts for your friends and family. Massive botnet returns from the dead, starts spamming The spam-spewing 'Srizbi' botnet that was shut down two weeks ago has been resurrected and is again under criminal control, say security researchers. Elgan: Why you can't trust 'friends' on Facebook Facebook is popular and growing -- especially with criminals. Here's why they love it. Windows 7 Get the latest news, reviews and more about Microsoft's newest desktop operating system More Continuing Coverage Windows 7 Voting Technology Google's Chrome browser Economy in turmoil: Latest news and tips iPhone 3G Bill Gates moves on Windows Vista A to Z Mac A to Z 2008 Salary Survey Find wage data for 50 IT job titles. More Special Reports 2008 Premier 100 IT Leaders 2007 Premier 100 IT Leaders 2008 Best Places to Work in IT 2007 Best Places to Work in IT 2008 Salary Survey 2007 Salary Survey 2006 Salary Survey 2008 IT Forecast 2007 IT Forecast 40 Years of Computerworld Top 12 Green-IT Users The FAQs About Going Green IT Schools to Watch iPhone: One Year Later Global Mobile Your Next Data Center Management: Reinventing IT Stop Data Leaks Web 2.0 Security Surviving Disasters Managing Storage Virtualization The Lean Storage Machine Storage on Trial Can Web 2.0 Save BI? Bypass These BI Potholes All Zones Business Continuity Zone The File Data Management Zone Security Management Zone The SAS Zone Business Intelligence and Analytics Zone The Enterprise Search Zone Software as a Service Zone The Security Zone See your link here

Symantec Backup Exec System Recovery-Restore Systems Anytime, from Anywhere to Virtually Any Device Download this white paper, FREE, compliments of Symantec! Restore Windows systems quickly, easily, and reliably to dissimilar hardware, virtual environments or in remote, unattended locations. Watch this Symantec webcast to learn how you can perform bare metal system recovery in minutes, meet and exceed service level agreements and recovery time objectives, and minimize requirements for remote on-site IT support. Download this executive briefing  Advances in SSL and Certificate Management Advances in SSL and Certificate Management View this webcast now! Go to the webcast  Windows Vista: Necessity and Opportunity Download this white paper today! (Novell) The Vista era of Windows is here. Yet most organizations will retain Windows XP alongside new Vista PCs for some time. Your challenge is to manage a mixed environment thus reducing the disruption of change, streamlining systems management and boosting end-user productivity so that your organization can better meet its business goals. Download this white paper  White Papers Read up on the latest ideas and technologies from companies that sell hardware, software and services. 8 Things You Need to Handle Today's Network Traffic Next-Gen Load Balancing: 3 Keys to Successful Delivery of Advanced Web Apps Building a Reliable and Dynamic Data Center with PAN Manager by Egenera View more whitepapers

• Windows users indifferent to Microsoft patch alarm, says researcher
• Microsoft slates 8 bug updates for year's final Patch Tuesday
• Tech jobs down sharply but not out
• More top stories 

Accelerate your pursuit of perfection For almost 80 years, Kodak has been helping banks, insurance companies, healthcare providers, government agencies and other businesses produce billions of document images. So Kodak is uniquely positioned to know and deliver–what customers want: easy-to-use scanners that output the best possible image quality. Download this white paper now!

Protecting Exchange While it was once just a convenient way for employees to communicate internally, today e-mail systems like Exchange are tightly integrated with other business applications and are one of the primary methods for communicating with current and prospective customers. Protecting Exchange against costly downtime has become a top priority for more IT departments. So how do you ensure that your Exchange environment is always protected? Download this white paper now!

Dan Tynan Today's Internet has been brought to you by porn YouTube and Ning are trying to shed adult-oriented content to appeal to mainstream advertisers. Will it work? ... [more]